Minimum wage worker protests raise awareness – but what about paychecks?


December 13, 2013

The protests have certainly been grabbing attention: ”Fast-food workers strike, protest for higher pay,” screams one national newspaper’s headline. “Public backs $10.10 minimum wage, not $15,” states another.

December 13, 2013

The protests have certainly been grabbing attention: ”Fast-food workers strike, protest for higher pay,” screams one national newspaper’s headline. “Public backs $10.10 minimum wage, not $15,” states another.

John White stands in the kitchen of his house earlier this year. White, who was profiled as part of a story on minimum wage workers earlier this year. is happy to be getting more hours at his job now.

For many minimum wage worker, the fatter paychecks probably haven’t materialized yet, however.

Experts say that while the nationwide effort to raise awareness about how tough it is to live on $7.25 an hour has resulted in some state and local increases, a nationwide push to eventually increase the federal minimum wage to $10.10 an hour appears to be facing significant Republican opposition.

“People feel like there’s probably limited likelihood of passage in the House of Representatives,” said Jack Temple, policy analyst with the National Employment Law Project, which has advocated for higher pay for low-wage workers.

Advocates such as Temple argue that what’s happened so far is still significant.

Temple said five states – California, New Jersey, Connecticut, Rhode Island and New York – enacted minimum-wage increases this year, and some cities also are pushing for similar hikes.

The Seattle suburb of SeaTac has drawn national attention after voters passed a measure to raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour for certain workers, despite strong objections from area businesses. But the effort faces a legal challenge.

Many more states are expected to take up similar fights next year, and advocates expect it to be a significant issue in the midterm elections next November.

“It’s easy, sometimes, for us to get discouraged when you see one or two states nudging the minimum wage up by a little bit here and a little bit there, but it does add up to something,” said Doug Hall, director of the Economic Analysis and Research Network for the liberal-leaning Economic Policy Institute. “There’s a sense of momentum.”

Arindrajit Dube, an associate professor economics at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst who studies minimum wage effects, said it’s historically significant to see fast-food workers and other low-wage employees publicly protesting.

“Where that leads to, I do not know,” he said. “But in the meantime, we should recognize that these are different patterns than we have seen in the past.”

Still, experts say that there are many states with more conservative legislatures where minimum wage workers will not likely see a wage increase unless there is a federal mandate to do so. The federal minimum wage was last increased, to $7.25 an hour, in mid-2009.

That’s left many low-wage workers watching the battle from the sidelines: They’re interested in the outcome, but it doesn’t affect their day-to-day lives yet.

Crystal Dupont and John White are two workers who were profiled by NBC News last March as part of the launch of our In Plain Sight project.

As 2013 comes to a close, NBC News asked White and Dupont to tell us, in their own words, how things are going for them now. Their responses have been edited for space and clarity.

John White: Living below my means, and grateful to God

In the last six months, things have improved for me. I still work at the same pizza restaurant, but the difference is that I'm getting more hours now.

John white

As you recall, I was only getting, on average, 7-1/2 hours for the whole entire week. Now, I'm getting close to 30 hours a week, and that helps me get more tips and certainly a healthier paycheck.

Other things have picked up for me. Throughout the summer I would spend a day down at my church mowing the lawn for them. Because of how the church has helped me in the last two-plus years with their benevolence ministry, I really feel good to give back by way of my time and service. Since working more hours, I don't have the same free time to volunteer, and besides, the mowing season is over.

Back in November, I also received my first deposit from Social Security. What a difference it's made for me. Just in that time after I received it, I had a situation where I needed two new tires for my Jeep. Instead of having to rely on my church helping me out, I was able to take care of them myself.

Along with that, I am now once again able to attend to paying all my own bills (without having to ask for help).

Just because I now will receive a monthly deposit from SSI doesn't mean that I'm going to stop working. Having both sources as a means of income has and will help give freedom back to me, as I had once before in my life, to be able to manage my money and breathe more of a sigh of relief from being "broke" all the time.

I find it interesting how there are all these threats of workers striking because they want to be paid $15 per hour. I certainly feel for them (because I was in that same position) but the $15, I think, is expecting too much. Something that would be more realistic would be $8.50 to $9, but that’s not for me to say.

As for me, I have learned to spend "below my means", and I feel much more content in life, and am only grateful that God saw me through it all.

Crystal Dupont: Out of work, but working hard at school

Crystal Dupont

I am no longer working that minimum wage job at home. Shortly after the story ran my hours dropped and I was let go.

I did find a part-time customer service job over the summer, but the employer refused to work with my schedule for the fall semester. It paid $10 an hour but with no benefits of any kind, and the hours were very inconvenient.

I am currently still enrolled in college. I took four classes this semester and I am doing excellent. My mother is doing fine.

I am still working hard towards school to achieve my degree in hopes of change. I am expected to graduate in May of 2015.

I have four finals coming up and I know I'll pass. Next semester I will be taking five classes and searching for temporary, full-time employment to fund my needs for classes and at home.

I am currently not working. Financially, to get by, over the summer I overpaid my bills. I still have some financial aid money that I am using, and I also have a little of my mom's support, along with my significant other. But he can only do so much, so I don't depend on him too often.

Courtesy: CNBC